Blog 13

Galan’s claim was that people don’t, or rather shouldn’t, have a narrative for themselves because as people we should only live life to experience it and not to tell a story at the end of the day. He says, “Life simply never assumes a story-like shape for us. And neither, from a moral point of view, should it”. This argument he makes, and the arguments he continually makes I can agree with up to certain extents. Like, I agree that life doesn’t have a picture perfect narrative for us(because if I did agree that would be naïve), but I don’t agree that our lives don’t hold enough meaning to become a narrative. We do things everyday, some more exciting than others, but we all have stories to tell if we search enough. When I hear someone say, “what’s your story”, I can then see Galen’s argument, but for me, it’s not the broad overall picture of what is our life story, but it is the small moments that make up our narrative. Galen wrote near the end of his article saying, “the narrative…might be important for some people in some cases. For most of us, however, I think self-knowledge comes best in bits and pieces”. Why cant ones narrative be their “bits and pieces” after all?

3 thoughts on “Blog 13”

  1. You make a very strong point in your blog. I totally agree with you that not everyone has a picture perfect narrative but I feel like we learn from those narratives that are not picture perfect. Your blog was really easy to understand and I enjoyed reading it!

  2. Jennie, I really liked your view and how you reacted to Strawson’s piece. I feel that even though she mentions how narratives can be “sugar coated” or not completely true, I think that just provides evidence as to the type of person they are. Similarly, you mention how some peoples stories are not exciting and maybe don’t think they have a narrative. But again, I think that this “boring” life story tells so much about their personality and character. Narratives can provide us with a lot of information about the individual.

  3. I think you do a great job of summarising (and wrestling with) Strawson’s main points. Great job!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *